Tafsir LabMethodGitHubTürkçe

al-Baqara 2:104 — The abandoning of a word

The Qurʾān · Sūra 2: al-Baqara · verse 104

This commentary was written by Claude (Anthropic); it carries no religious authority and should be checked against the classical sources.

2/104

2/104 — The abandoning of a word

"You who believe! Do not say 'rāʿinā', say 'unẓurnā', and listen."

A verse that looks small, but is extremely interesting.

رَاعِنَا — root r-ʿ-y: to watch over, to shepherd. In Arabic it is an entirely innocent expression: "watch over us", "attend to us", in the sense of slowing down while speaking. The Companions used this word in addressing the Prophet.

The trouble is this: the same sequence of sounds, said a little differently or in another language, could carry a demeaning sense. According to what is transmitted, some began to use the word for exactly that reason, with a slight bending — an insult for the speaker, an ordinary request for the hearer.

The solution is striking: the word is forbidden. No culprit is found and punished, no intention is examined; instead a synonym is proposed: unẓurnā — "look at us, attend to us". The meaning is the same, the sound different, the possibility of abuse gone.

The measure that follows is this: how a word is understood also falls within the speaker's field of responsibility. An expression may be correct in itself; but if it is open to being misunderstood or misused, its correctness does not make it defensible. And the solution is not to blame the other side but to change the expression.

This sets up an interesting symmetry with verse 59 of the sūra: there the word given was changed in bad faith; here it is changed in good faith. The same act, two directions.


The whole of Sūrat al-Baqara