قُل لَّوْ أَنتُمْ تَمْلِكُونَ خَزَآئِنَ رَحْمَةِ رَبِّىٓ إِذًا لَّأَمْسَكْتُمْ خَشْيَةَ ٱلْإِنفَاقِ وَكَانَ ٱلْإِنسَٰنُ قَتُورًا
Qul law antum tamlikūna khazāʾina raḥmati rabbī idhan la-amsaktum khashyata'l-infāq, wa kāna'l-insānu qatūrā
"Say: 'If you possessed the treasuries of my Lord's mercy, you would still hold them back for fear of spending.' Man is exceedingly grudging."
The same word, in two places in the sūra and for two different fears. This is a repetition that can be verified within the sūra.
And I record this as my own reading; its support is the comparison of the two verses: in the thirty-first verse what was feared was not having; here what is feared is the diminishing of what one has. The verse says that the two situations produce the same disposition — and shows it by way of a conditional sentence, as a test: even if you possessed the treasuries.
The root was treated at 25/67 in al-Furqān (wa lam yaqturū), and it was recorded there as one of the two extremes of spending. I rely on that treatment.
And its link within the sūra must be recorded: the twenty-ninth verse had described the same state by an image (yadaka maghlūlatan ilā ʿunuqik). The hundredth verse names the same state with a word: qatūr.
| Verse | Expression |
|---|---|
| 11 | Wa kāna'l-insānu ʿajūlā — hasty |
| 67 | Wa kāna'l-insānu kafūrā — ungrateful |
| 83 | Kāna yaʾūsā — despairing |
| 100 | Wa kāna'l-insānu qatūrā — grudging |
Four places, four separate attributes, and all with kāna. And in the seventieth verse the same being is called karramnā (We have honoured).
I record this as my own reading, and its support is the standing side by side of these five verses: the sūra says two things at once about the human being — that he has been honoured, and that he carries four separate faults. The two do not cancel one another.