Tafsir LabMethodGitHubTürkçe

al-Jinn 72:27

The Qurʾān · Sūra 72: al-Jinn · verse 27

This commentary was written by Claude (Anthropic); it carries no religious authority and should be checked against the classical sources.

72/27

إِلَّا مَنِ ارْتَضَىٰ مِن رَّسُولٍ فَإِنَّهُ يَسْلُكُ مِن بَيْنِ يَدَيْهِ وَمِنْ خَلْفِهِ رَصَدًا

Illā mani'rtaḍā min rasūlin fa-innahu yasluku min bayni yadayhi wa min khalfihī raṣadā

"Except a messenger with whom He is well pleased; and then He stations watchers before him and behind him."

إِلَّا مَنِ ارْتَضَىٰ — "except one with whom He is well pleased"

Root ر-ض-و: to be pleased, to be content, to approve and accept. This root was taken up in the sections on al-Bayyina and al-Ghāshiya; the reciprocity of riḍā was dwelt on there.

اِرْتَضَىٰ is in the iftiʿāl form and conveys here choosing and approving: not at random but by preference.

The exception, then, is bound by two conditions:

1. Being a messenger (min rasūlin). 2. Being chosen (irtaḍā).

The second condition limits the first as well: not every messenger, but the messenger with whom He is pleased. And the subject of the verb is God — the one who chooses is not the messenger himself.

This opens the door of knowledge of the unseen and narrows it at the same moment. The door exists but its lock is on the outside: no one can enter by his own decision.

The link with the head of the sūra

This verse is the rule of verse 1.

In verse 1 the Prophet said "it was revealed to me" — he had received a report of an event he could not see. In that section this was recorded: "The Prophet does not know the unseen; he knows what is notified to him of the unseen."

Verse 27 is the general expression of that sentence. The sūra opens with an instance and closes with the rule:

72/172/26-27
WhatAn event: the jinn's listening was notifiedA rule: the unseen is opened only to a chosen messenger
MoodPassive: ūḥiya — "it was revealed"Active: lā yuẓhiru — "He does not give access"
EmphasisThe manner of the knowledge's comingThe owner of the knowledge

فَإِنَّهُ يَسْلُكُ — "He stations"

The verb returns from verse 17. There it was yaslukhu ʿadhāban ṣaʿadā — "He drives him into a mounting punishment". Here it is yasluku … raṣadā — "He stations watchers".

The same verb, in two separate works. The root's sense (to pass a thing into a place, to insert) is the same in both; what changes is what is inserted where: in the one a person into punishment, in the other a guard onto a road.

Who is the agent? The pronoun refers to God (it is transmitted that in some commentaries it is referred to the messenger, but the context indicates God: the subject of the verb irtaḍā is He too).

مِن بَيْنِ يَدَيْهِ وَمِنْ خَلْفِهِ — "before him and behind him"

Bayna yadayhi — literally "between his two hands", that is, in front of him. Khalfihībehind him.

This pair is a widespread pattern in the Qurʾān and conveys encompassment: all the directions of a thing. The wholeness we mean in English by "front and back".

To whom does the pronoun refer? There are two possibilities:

ViewThe pronounSense
1To the messengerWatchers are set before and behind the messenger; the messenger is protected.
2To the revelation / to the unseen notifiedWatchers are set before and behind what is notified; the message is protected.

The two readings do not exclude one another; to protect the messenger is to protect the message.

رَصَدًا — the word of verse 9 has returned

This is the most elegant internal link of the sūra and was pointed to at verse 9; here it is completed.

The word is from the root ر-ص-د and was taken up at verse 9: to watch, to wait in ambush; mirṣād (a place of watching, al-Fajr 89/14), marṣad (al-Tawba 9/5).

Now let us set the two occurrences side by side:

72/972/27
The sentenceyajid lahu shihāban raṣadāyasluku … raṣadā
Against whomThe one trying to steal knowledgeThe one trying to spoil the revelation
Its functionTo block — to close the entranceTo protect — to secure the carriage
Its positionAt the gate of the heavenBefore and behind the messenger

The same watching, at the two ends of the channel.

This completes the sūra's argument on the matter of knowledge. The question asked throughout the sūra was: where does this word come from? And the addressee's supposition was: from the jinn, from where the soothsayers get theirs.

The answer is given in two steps:

1. That channel is closed (8-9). And it is those who used the channel who say so. 2. This channel, however, is guarded (27). With watchers before it and behind it.

That is, the revelation comes by a road that is both closed to illicit entry and guarded while it is carried. The Qurʾān sets up this claim plainly elsewhere too: "The satans did not bring it down… They are kept far from hearing" (al-Shuʿarāʾ 26/210-212); "It is not the word of an accursed satan" (al-Takwīr 81/25).


Roots analysed in this section

ر-ص-د

The whole of Sūrat al-Jinn